Mental Health Billing Questions for Therapists in Private Practice

Insurance billing questions keep therapists up at night. Here are answers to the ones I hear most often. Some questions deserve a longer conversation — I’ll point you to resources or a consultation when that’s the case.

Jump to a section:

Coordination of Benefits

Your client either has another insurance policy that should be billed first, or the insurance company is checking whether another policy exists. You won’t get paid until your client takes action! Download a client explanation letter here.

That’s complicated! The insurance industry has pages and pages of rules published that determines the order in which plans are billed. Your client doesn’t get to choose. Which insurance is “primary” can be based on multiple factors. If you subscribe to my newsletter, you’ll be able to download a guide to determining coordination of benefits order (how to tell which plans are primary vs secondary) for free!

Probably not. I made a free video explaining exactly what to do in this situation.

Once a claim is denied/pended for COB, don’t resubmit it. The client first has to call and update their record with the insurer. You’ll save yourself some work if you tell your client to ask the insurance company to “reprocess” the claim. If the insurer doesn’t, you have to appeal. You can do this by filing a dispute/appeal on their portal, stating that the client called in their COB information (and give the date + reference number). Or, call in and request reprocessing, giving them the same information.

Still getting no results? I can help! Or consider writing a “badass executive dispute letter”!

Medicare

That’s an individual decision and should be made by carefully examining your practice. What are your goals for your practice? What kinds of clients do you enjoy working with? What sort of community do you practice in? Opting out may have unintended consequences for participation with commercial insurance plans. Realize that opting out means a 2-year lockout from Medicare, so it’s not a decision to be made lightly or because you’re intimidated by Medicare (which is a completely understandable feeling!) For a written FAQ about Medicare opt-out, click here. And here’s a webinar that explores the various considerations when deciding to enroll vs. opt out.

Yes, if they’re willing to pay cash and understand there will be no reimbursement from Medicare. You’ll need to have them sign a private contract. The Medicare opt-out FAQ has all the details.

There is no such thing. Only psychiatrists are allowed to enroll as “non-participating.”

Opting out of Medicare is easy to do – one quick form! But there are quite a few rules, nuances, and cautions to be aware of, because once you opt out, you’re locked out for two years! It can affect your ability to practice with other payers and at other locations. Get all the facts here.

Trying to get a denial for a secondary payer if you’re not enrolled with Medicare. It won’t happen! If you’re enrolled, common mistakes are 1) not verifying eligibility, which means you may inadvertently be billing Medicare when the client has a commercial “Advantage” plan. And 2) not following up with payment from supplemental payers, which can be difficult to do if your EHR doesn’t have the correct functionality. Since supplements/secondary payers account for 20% of your Medicare revenue, that can be a lot of money left on the table. Feeling confused by Medicare? Here’s a training webinar where you can learn what you don’t know!

Medicare Advantage plans review all diagnosis codes of their enrolled members after a plan year is over. Their goal is to try to see if they can increase their reimbursement from the government. This blog explains how it works and how to respond in compliance with HIPAA guidelines.

Two years and it will renew automatically unless cancelled. 

It’s the ONLY way to bill Medicare patients directly. 

Deciding whether or not to enroll or opt-out of Medicare is an important decision which can have far-reaching effects on your practice. You owe it to yourself to consider all the ramifications before making a decision that could cost you significant income. This recorded webinar reviews all your options.

This product contains everything you want to know about Medicare opt-outs.

Insurance Denials & Appeals

A rejection never makes it to the insurance payer – if you call about it, you’ll be told the claim isn’t on file. 

A denial means the insurance has refused to pay – and now the detective work begins on how to make them pay!

This webinar shows you how to ensure as many claims as possible are successfully transmitted on the first try, and gives you tools to challenge denials when they occur.

That will depend on the type of plan and how long the plan allows to submit appeals following a denial. If you’re in-network, appeals timeframe may also be dictated by your provider contract.

That decision is going to be somewhat personal. You’ll want to assess how much time you think pursuing the denial will take vs what your time is worth financially. How much are you owed? But there’s more to it: are you still seeing the client? Are the denials likely to spread to other clients? This can quickly become a complex decision as there are many factors involved. Scheduling a consultation might help clarify things. And, I might be able to intervene and fix the denial for you with less hassle!

Credentialing

Depends on the insurance company. I’ve seen everything from 10 days to 1.5 years! On average, the usual timeframes are 45-90 days. Some states are starting to mandate shorter turnaround times (30-60 days). Keep in mind that “credentialing” is just a background check. The next step to getting added to an insurance panel is “contracting,” and that process is figured into the total timeframes I quoted. You can minimize the time your application takes by being quick to respond to requests for additional information, by keeping CAQH updated, and completing the forms correctly. Here’s a webinar that might help you with this.

No. To bill as if someone else was performing the service would be considered a false claim, in other words, insurance fraud.

Because they have a special arrangement with the insurance companies (who in many cases are also their investors), to perform credentialing under what’s called a “delegated” arrangement. In this instance, the platform is doing the credentialing of you, not the insurance company. Then they simply notify the insurance company that you’re providing services under their contract. It saves the insurance companies money in terms of hiring internal employees to do credentialing and then contracting. In return, the insurance then pays the platform more favorable rates – and as investors, they share in the profits of the platform.

You can, but it will be paid at the out of network benefit level, assuming the client has out of network benefits. I offer a webinar where you can learn the secrets of the credentialing process.

General Billing

There are lots of choices out there! The one your suitemate uses may not be the best one for YOU! This blog gives some idea of just how many features software platforms offer. And it’s not just billing. You have to consider the clinical records aspect, telehealth, scheduling, patient portal, e-prescribe (if applicable), and more! I consult with practices to identify their software needs and pair them with the best product for their needs and price point – and I’m objective! I take no money from the software vendors to preferentially recommend them.

Resubmitting means you’re sending it again – which you shouldn’t do unless there’s a correction that needs to be made, or if the insurance rejected it the first time, or if they say they didn’t get it. Reprocessing means you make a request to the insurance company that they change their decision on how they adjudicated the claim, because you or the client think their decision was in error. You do this either by calling in the request, sending a portal message, or filling out a form. Or, your client can initiate the request also.

Still not sure which one applies to your situation? Book a consultation.

This blog explains the basic differences. Knowing whether it’s allowed is tricky. Some insurers do allow it, but others only for in-network, or for groups, or in certain states. And then, even if it is allowed, the methods of actually billing vary! Here’s a webinar that goes over the topic in detail!

It’s possible, especially if you’ve been paneled for a while and have a history of good clinical outcomes and a low volume of complaints. OR, if you’re in a high-need specialty or geographic area.

There’s a strategy to negotiating – and unfortunately a sample letter just doesn’t work well. Sure, it might get you up to $5 more per code, but in tough economic times that’s becoming harder and harder. To get meaningful increases, the best way to do it is analyze your practice’s strengths and weaknesses with respect to your market. And to do THAT, you need hard data! Insurance payers are obliged to share reimbursement rates publicly. Yes, really!

I have access to the rates, and I can help you develop an individualized strategy/request letter, and I can even give you emails of insurance company executives to make your request. Because sending into a general customer service mailbox is a guarantee that if you hear back from them at all, it may be in 9-12 months!

I find that lately, out of network practices are encountering insurance issues as well, because clients are trying to use out of network benefits. And unlike a practice that accepts insurance contracts, if you’re out of network, you may have nowhere to turn for support. I can help!

If you can sustain a practice without insurance, that’s absolutely the way to go, and I’ll never say otherwise!  😊  However, my background doesn’t include marketing a practice, beyond a few obvious tips I’ve picked up over the years. There are any number of practice-building coaches and training programs out there. Pick one that resonates with you if you want the support. Although a word of caution: in my experience, a 6- or 7- figure cash-only practice takes years to develop, progress will be slow, and there are some communities in the US where it may never be realistic. Only you know whether cash-0nly will work for your situation, clinical niche, and community. Just remember, you’re no less of a competent therapist if you accept insurance. Being contracted with insurance is a business decision. It has no bearing on your skills as a clinician.

Some of my content deals with leaving insurance and many of the practices I consult with are out of network.  Definitely, not all insurance panels are the same. You may find some easier to deal with than others, and it never hurts to start by leaving the one or two that pay the least and/or give you the most hassle.

Upcoming EVENTS

Medicare Made Easy!

I hear all the time: "I wouldn't mind taking Medicare but it's just so hard!"  For everyone who's said that to me, here's Medicare Made Easy! You might want to...

$45.00

Guest appearance:

Ethical Practice Under Pressure: Navigating Insurance, Financial, and Systemic Challenges

Join the Western Oregon Mental Health Alliance (WOMHA) on Friday, October 30, 2026, 9am–12pm PT for a live 3-hour CE webinar with the amazing Susan Frager, PsychBilling Coach, to tackle the tricky insurance, billing, and Medicare dilemmas therapists face every day, plus how to handle the ones with no perfect answer.